The core reason for prioritizing G10/G11 (epoxy glass cloth board) over GPO-3 for oil immersed equipment
Summary in one sentence: *Epoxy resin has a stable chemical structure and is resistant to mineral transformer oil; GPO-3 is an unsaturated polyester that slowly swells and corrodes by mineral oil.
1. Differences in oil resistance performance of matrix resins (fundamental)
-G10/G11: Epoxy resin
After epoxy curing, it is mainly composed of ether bonds, with strong chemical inertness and almost no swelling or dissolution reaction with mineral transformer oil (alkanes/cycloalkanes).
Transformer oil will not penetrate into the resin matrix, and after long-term immersion:
-Stable size, extremely low expansion rate
-The weight change is minimal
-Mechanical strength, dielectric strength, and dielectric loss remain stable
G11 has a higher heat resistance level and a more stable high-temperature oil environment compared to G10.
-GPO-3: Unsaturated polyester resin
The curing system contains a large number of ester bonds. Mineral oil will slowly infiltrate into the resin at room temperature/high temperature, causing swelling:
Oil molecules enter the resin glass fiber felt interface, gradually peeling off the resin and glass fibers, causing delamination and bubbling. The higher the temperature (oil changes to 80-105 ℃), the faster the aging rate.
The GPO-3 standard includes a short-term oil breakdown test, which only measures insulation for a short period of time and does not represent long-term immersion durability.
2. Enhanced substrate difference: glass cloth vs glass felt
-G10/G11: * * Continuous glass cloth * * woven structure, dense. Resin infiltration is sufficient, interlayer bonding is strong, and oil is difficult to penetrate along interlayer gaps.
-GPO-3: * * Short cut glass felt * *, with larger pores than glass cloth. Oil is more likely to seep into the interior of the board through the pores of the felt layer, accelerating delamination.
3. Rigid requirements for insulation components in oil immersed equipment
Internal working conditions of oil immersed transformers/transformers:
1. Long term high temperature (80-105 ℃)+continuous soaking in mineral oil
2. Cold hot cycle, thermal expansion and contraction
3. The size of the insulation components must be stable and cannot deform or squeeze the winding
4. Do not precipitate substances to contaminate transformer oil (once the dielectric loss and acid value of the oil increase, the entire equipment will be scrapped)
-G10/G11: After immersion in oil, there is almost no precipitation of small molecules, which will not pollute the transformer oil. The physical and chemical indicators of the oil remain stable, which is the most important point for oil transformers.
-When GPO-3 is exposed to hot oil for a long time, the resin will slowly degrade, and small molecules will dissolve into the transformer oil, increasing the acid value and dielectric loss of the oil, causing oil degradation, and in severe cases, leading to partial discharge and breakdown risks.
4. Long term stability of electrical performance
-G10/G11: Long term immersion in oil results in minimal changes in dielectric strength, partial discharge performance, and dielectric loss.
-GPO-3: With oil absorption and swelling, the dielectric loss gradually increases, and air gaps are formed at the interface, which can easily lead to partial discharge and insulation failure over time.







